Mackinac Island Fudge: Order Online for the Holidays

Published on December 5th, 2021

Last updated on December 3rd, 2022

A trip to Mackinac Island wouldn’t be complete without stopping to get everyone’s favorite sweet treat! With daily fudge-making demonstrations, the sweet scent of fudge being blown out on the sidewalks to draw visitors in, and a title like Fudge Capital of the World, it’s easy to see why Mackinac Island Fudge is almost as famous as Mackinac Island itself.

And while many Mackinac Island businesses close their storefronts and offer online sales, specific days, and by appointment shopping only from November through early April, Mackinac Island fudge is available online year-round making it a perfect holiday gift idea! Read on to find out more Mackinac Island fudge details and be sure to visit the websites of Joann’s Fudge, Original Murdick’s Fudge, and Ryba’s Fudge to order fudge online year-round.


Over 100 years ago, Mackinac Island was shifting from the center of the fur trade to a summer resort destination. In 1887, Mackinac Island’s first candy shop opened as Murdick’s Candy Kitchen. Using Sara Murdick’s original recipe, the Murdick family started making fudge and used big marble slabs to draw out the heat and cool the fudge evenly. These marble slabs were displayed at the front of the store where visitors could watch how fudge was made.You can order world-famous Mackinac Island fudge online for holiday gifts even though storefronts close for winter.

Suddenly, fudge-making became a public event. Fudge demonstrations kept visitors mesmerized as they watched makers heat the ingredients to over 230 degrees, pour the melted mixture onto giant marble slabs, and use large paddles to fold the fudge over and over until it eventually became a “loaf.”

In the 1960’s multiple fudge shops had stores on Mackinac Island. In addition to Murdick’s Fudge, Harry Ryba and his son-in-law Victor Callewaert opened the first Ryba’s Fudge Shop, Joan and Frank Nephew opened Joann’s Fudge Store, and Harold May operated May’s Candy Shop.

The fudge stores got creative and even used kitchen fans to blow out the scent of fudge onto the streets to passing guests. The sweet smells would stop visitors in their tracks and draw them into the fudge shop to try samples and purchase fudge.

By the 1960’s the abundance of visitors to Mackinac Island were affectionately known as “fudgies” for their enthusiasm for Mackinac Island’s famous treat. Today visitors are still known by locals as fudgies and there are 7 fudge businesses on Mackinac Island with 13 storefronts in the downtown area. You’re never far from a fudge shop on Mackinac Island!

The same presentation tactics that were used over 100 years ago are still used today. You’ll find fudge makers working over big marble slabs behind large windows creating the perfect fudge loaf. Every block you’ll catch a whiff of fudge as it pulls you into another fudge shop. And trying samples from each shop is a favorite way to determine who officially has the best Mackinac Island fudge. The seven Mackinac Island fudge businesses are Joann’s Fudge, Kilwins Chocolate & Fudge Shop, May’s Fudge & Candy Shop, Murray Hotel Fudge, Original Murdick’s Fudge, Ryba’s Fudge Shops, and Sander’s Fudge & Candy.


Mackinac Island attracts many “fudgies” who visit to enjoy free samples of world-famous Mackinac Island fudge.While many Mackinac Island storefronts may be closed in the off-season, Mackinac Island fudge is available by ordering online year-round! If you’re looking for a Mackinac Island-themed gift, including Mackinac Island fudge is always a good idea. Many of the shops have holiday specials and seasonal flavors during the winter season. They also have more information on shipping dates to make sure the fudge is delivered in time for your celebrations.

The three fudge shops you can order Mackinac Island fudge from are Joann’s Fudge on Mackinac Island, Mackinac Island’s Original Murdick’s Fudge, and Ryba’s Fudge Shops on Mackinac Island. Visit their websites for more details on how to order Mackinac Island fudge and give the gift of Mackinac Island to those you love this holiday season.